July budget execution: bottom-line surprises on the upside, revenues on the downside

MoF data on July budget execution show that, after a temporary rebound in June, revenues (excl. tax refunds) resumed their downward trend easing by 18.6% y-o-y in July and bringing the 7-month figure down 6.9% y-o-y to€27.9bn. Furthermore, 7M’12 revenues continued falling short of targets at an accelerating pace (by €2.2bn in 7M’12 compared to €1.0bn in 6M’12), mainly reflecting lower-than-anticipated income tax revenues, due to the extension given to income tax declarations, and  – to a lesser extent – transactions taxes, also attributed, in my view, to the 2-month election period.

On the contrary, primary expenditure continued heading south for sixth month in a row easing by 17.4% in July, following a drop of 14.1% in June and 16.6% in May, bringing the 7-month figure down 8.6% y-o-y to €27.6bn and beating 7-month target by €2.0bn or 6.7%.

Interest payments dropped 0.8% y-o-y (for the first time so far in 2012) to €10.1bn. The FY’12 target calls for a 20% drop. It is noteworthy that the bulk of 7M’12 interest payments (€6.1bn) was recorded in March and related to the implementation of PSI.

Overall, 7-month deficit slipped 17.4% y-o-y (for the first time a double-digit drop so far in 2012) to €13.2bn. I also point out that bottom-line was supported by the significant positive contribution of Public Investment Budget (PIB), which exhibited a deficit of €0.5bn in 7M’12 from €1.4bn last year. Nevertheless, even excluding PIB, deficit would have fallen 12.5% y-o-y to €12.7bn. Furthermore, 7-month reported figure bettered 7-month target by €1.6bn or 11.0%, a softer performance compared to 6M’12, when bottom-line was €2.4bn better-than-expected, yet still providing a cushion for the fiscal adjustment efforts in the coming months.

Primary balance turned positive in July (for the first time since February) with primary surplus reaching €0.25bn in July from deficit of €1.0bn in June and €0.6bn in May. Furthermore, 7-month primary deficit stood at €3.1bn (down 46.8% y-o-y) significantly beating 7-month target by €1.5bn or 32.3%, still continuing to surprise on the upside.

Over the last four months, bottom-line retains a constantly improving trend: Budget deficit, which stood at €1.9bn in April, gradually eased to €1.7bn in May, €1.6bn in June and €0.7bn in July. Primary balance performance followed a similar pattern with primary deficit slipping from €1.4bn in April to €0.6bn in May and to €1.0bn in June turning to surplus of €0.25bn in July. Bottom-line evolution reflects a better – both in absolute numbers and relative to targets- performance of expenditure more than offsetting a widening revenue shortfall.

This entry was posted in Greek economy and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s